SCI, SCS or decyl glucoside: what are the differences for a solid shampoo?
Key takeaways
- SCI favors a dense lather and a gentle cleansing base
- SCS favors a rich lather and a firm bar structure
-
While decyl glucoside is mainly used as a liquid co-surfactant to adjust gentleness and ease of processing.
SCI, SCS and decyl glucoside: comparison table
| Criterion | SCI | SCS | Decyl glucoside | SLES 27% Ecocert |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Category | Anionic | Sulfated anionic | Nonionic | Sulfated anionic |
| Arcane Direct product form | White powder | Needle-shaped particles | Viscous liquid, clear to slightly cloudy | Colorless liquid |
| Foam profile | Dense and creamy | Abundant and stable | Foam booster and stabilizer when combined with other surfactants | Foaming agent for liquid bases |
| Role in the formulation | Mild base for syndet bars and solid shampoos | Solid base when foam and cleaning performance take priority | Liquid co-surfactant and mildness agent | Liquid alternative, especially for shampoos and gels |
| Published pH | 4–6 to 10% in water at 35 °C | Not published on the accessible product page | 11–12.5 for the raw material; stated in-use pH: 4.5–7.5 | 10.5–12 at 10%; stated in-use pH: 5.5–7 |
| Dosage | Calculate based on active content and validate in a pilot trial | Calculate based on active content and validate in a pilot trial | Adjust according to the water added and the desired hardness | Convert based on 26.5–28% active content |
| Published compatibilities | Nonionic and amphoteric surfactants; combination with decyl glucoside | Combination with SCI or decyl glucoside | Compatible with different types of surfactants | Can be combined with decyl glucoside, coco betaine, or SCI |
| Documented status shown | COSMOS-compliant on the product page; discrepancy with the collection page to be verified | Ecocert, COSMOS, and REACH indicated | Ecocert, COSMOS, and REACH indicated | Verified by Ecocert; ECODETERGENT and COSMOS indicated |
Methodological point: the pH of the raw material or a test dilution does not replace the pH of the finished formula. Measure the product under the conditions specified in your quality protocol and validate the method for the solid format.
Which surfactant should you choose for a solid shampoo?
SCI: prioritize creamy foam and a mild product profile
Sodium Cocoyl Isethionate, or SCI, is available as a white powder with a stated minimum content of 82% by weight. It is suitable for solid shampoos, syndet bars, and facial cleansers when lather texture and perceived mildness are key requirements. Its powder form, however, requires dust extraction, appropriate PPE, and a validated incorporation method.
Incorporation in solid or molten form is indicated at 70–80 °C, with a recommended formulation pH of 4.5–7. These parameters must remain compatible with the other ingredients, fragrance, active ingredients, and the actual production process.
SCS: prioritize abundant foam and bar integrity
Sodium Coco Sulfate, or SCS, is an anionic surfactant in needle form with a stated active matter content of over 90%. It is suitable for solid shampoos and cleansing bars designed to produce abundant, stable lather. Its needle form makes it easier to source as a solid, but its tolerability, rinse-off performance, and effect on hair fibers should be compared with SCI in the finished formulation.
We specify incorporation into the molten solid phase at 70 to 80 °C and recommend combining it with a liquid surfactant to facilitate processing. The site does not publish a specific usage pH for this grade.
Decyl glucoside: a liquid co-surfactant for adjusting the formula
Decyl glucoside is a viscous liquid nonionic surfactant. It can be combined with SCI, SCS, or SLES to provide wetting, support lather, and improve overall mildness. In a solid shampoo, it can help bind a powdered base together but increases the liquid fraction of the paste.
This liquid phase must be included in the formulation balance. An uncontrolled increase can affect the bar’s hardness, drying time, stability, and microbial control. The stated pH of the ingredient itself is 11 to 12.5, while the stated use range is 4.5 to 7.5; the final pH must therefore be measured after combining the ingredients.
SLES 27%: a liquid-base alternative, not a direct equivalent
Sodium Laureth Sulfate at 27% is a useful benchmark for liquid shampoos, shower gels, and cleansers. Its listed Ecocert grade contains 26.5% to 28% active matter: replacing a solid surfactant with this product without adjusting for active content substantially changes the water contribution and total active matter.
For a solid bar, treat it as a distinct processing option, not a gram-for-gram replacement for SCI or SCS.
Build a surfactant system rather than choose a single ingredient
In a professional formulation, the right choice often involves a system rather than a single raw material. SCI can form the main base of a syndet designed to produce creamy lather, while a portion of decyl glucoside can help adjust wetting, paste cohesion, and the sensory profile. Another formulation may combine SCS with a liquid co-surfactant when the priorities are rapid lather formation and bar integrity.
These combinations should be compared at a constant total active matter content so the test measures the effect of the ratio, rather than a simple change in cleansing power.
Formulation tip: if the bar crumbles, softens, foams slowly, or rinses poorly, adjust the surfactant blend, liquid fraction, and structuring system separately. A short test plan with a control and a few clearly documented ratios produces more reliable results than a series of recipes that change several parameters at once.
Plan for the transition from lab to production
The supplied form directly affects the process:
- Powdered SCI requires weighing methods that limit dust generation and controlled transfer;
- Needle-form SCS does not behave the same way in a hopper, mixer, or during compaction.
- Conversely, liquid decyl glucoside and SLES 27% require checking pumpability, dosing accuracy, losses on vessel walls, and line cleaning.
The best result obtained in a beaker is therefore not necessarily the most reproducible at production scale.
Parameters to record during scale-up: mixing time, actual batch temperature, order of addition, mixer torque, and yield after demolding or extrusion. Also factor transfer losses, cleaning time, heating energy, scrap, and the active ingredient actually incorporated into the cost of use.
Compare dosages on an active matter basis
Comparing products by their supplied percentages is misleading. A formulation containing 10 kg of SLES at 27% provides approximately 2.7 kg of active matter, whereas a solid stated to contain over 90% provides more than 9 kg for the same supplied weight.
Active matter supplied = raw material weight × active matter fraction.
For SCI, SCS, and SLES, use the batch value or certificate of analysis when formulation accuracy requires it. Final dosage ranges depend on the product, frequency of use, tolerability target, and evaluation protocol.
Laboratory screening protocol
- Set the targets: foam, hardness, dissolution rate, rinsing, hair type, frequency of use and certification standard.
- Standardize trials by active matter content: do not compare raw materials at the same as-supplied weight.
- Build a small test matrix: an SCI base, an SCS base, then variants with decyl glucoside at comparable active matter levels.
- Measure the final pH using a documented method: specify dilution, temperature and equilibration time.
- Test the finished product: hardness, weight loss, foam, rinsing, combability, stability, water activity and microbiology if the formula contains an aqueous phase.
- Finalize the supplier documentation: technical data sheet, safety data sheet, INCI name, certificate of analysis, origin and Ecocert or COSMOS supporting documentation.
Compatibility and formulation mistakes to avoid
- Do not confuse physical form with mildness: a powder or needle-shaped particles do not determine how well the finished formula will be tolerated.
- Do not substitute gram for gram: the four products differ in both active matter content and water contribution.
- Do not adjust pH based solely on the raw material: test the finished formula using a defined method.
- Do not claim Ecocert certification by extension: an ingredient’s eligibility does not automatically certify the finished product.
- Do not overlook dust: powdered SCI requires weighing and transfer procedures that limit exposure.
Professional and regulatory considerations
Operator safety: consult the safety data sheet for each batch. Define PPE, ventilation and cleaning measures according to physical form: dust for SCI, needle-shaped particles for SCS and splashes for liquid grades.
Cosmetic compliance: bringing the finished product to market requires, among other things, a safety assessment, a product information file, good manufacturing practices, CPNP notification and evidence supporting the claims made.
Storage and waste: keep powders and needle-shaped materials dry, containers closed and labeled, and store liquids according to their product sheets. Manage tank residues, wash water and packaging according to their classification and the site’s disposal channels; do not discharge into the drainage system without approval.
Need help choosing your surfactants?
Need to balance gentleness, foaming power, bar hardness, and Ecocert or COSMOS eligibility?
Send your target formula, desired active matter, process, and certification requirements to the Arcane Direct technical team.
Product(s) featured in this article



